Eyeshadow is a versatile makeup product that can elevate any makeup look. It comes in a range of colors and finishes, making it easy to create a variety of eye-catching looks. Whether you prefer a natural, everyday look or a bold, colorful statement, there is an eyeshadow out there for you.
When it comes to choosing the best makeup eyeshadow, there are several factors to consider. The first is the formula. Some eyeshadows are powders, while others are creams or liquids. Each formula has its pros and cons, so it’s essential to choose one that suits your needs and preferences.
Another critical factor to consider is the pigmentation. High-pigment eyeshadows provide vibrant color payoff with just one swipe, while lower-pigment formulas may require several layers to achieve the desired intensity.
We spent hours researching and testing various eyeshadows to identify the eight best makeup eyeshadows on the market. Whether you’re looking for a matte, shimmer, or metallic finish, we’ve got you covered. Our top picks offer excellent pigmentation, blendability, and longevity, making them perfect for any occasion.
This post may contain affiliate links, which means I’ll receive a commission if you purchase through my link, at no extra cost to you. Please read full disclosure here.
Best Makeup Eyeshadow
We’ve scoured the market to bring you the best of the best in makeup eyeshadows. Whether you’re looking for bold and bright colors or subtle and natural shades, we’ve got you covered. Our team of expert testers has put these products to the test to ensure that they provide long-lasting wear and vibrant pigmentation. So, without further ado, here are our top picks for the best makeup eyeshadows on Amazon.
Jolilab Eyeshadow Stick Set
We highly recommend the Jolilab Eyeshadow Stick Set for anyone looking for a versatile and affordable eyeshadow option.
Pros
- The set includes 8 matte eyeshadow sticks that are highly pigmented and provide a vivid, bright look.
- The eyeshadow sticks are multi-purpose and can be used for contouring or highlighting as well.
- The Jolilab Eyeshadow Stick Set makes a great gift and is perfect for any occasion.
Cons
- The colors in the set may not be suitable for everyone’s preferences.
- The eyeshadow sticks may not be as long-lasting as some other options on the market.
- The texture of the eyeshadow sticks may be too creamy for some users.
The Jolilab Eyeshadow Stick Set is easy to use and provides a smooth, even finish. The eyeshadow sticks are highly pigmented and provide a bold, crease-resistant color that is perfect for any occasion. The set includes 8 colors that can be used individually or combined to create a variety of looks.
The eyeshadow sticks are waterproof and sweat-proof, making them perfect for all-day wear. They are also quick-drying and do not fade, ensuring that your makeup stays looking fresh and vibrant all day long.
The Jolilab Eyeshadow Stick Set is perfect for beginners and experts alike. The soft and creamy texture of the eyeshadow sticks makes them easy to blend and master, even for those who are new to applying eyeshadow. The eyeshadow sticks are also retractable, making them easy to use and apply without the need for brushes.
In conclusion, the Jolilab Eyeshadow Stick Set is a versatile and affordable option for anyone looking for a high-quality eyeshadow set. With its bold, crease-resistant color and easy-to-use texture, this set is perfect for any occasion and makes a great gift for friends and family.
MAEPEOR Matte Liquid Eyeshadow 8 Colors Neutral Naked Smooth Creamy Eyeshadow Lightweight High-pigmented and Waterproof Long Lasting Eyeshadow (Matte Naked, 8Colors Set 1) (Set 1, Matte Naked)
If you’re looking for a natural and neutral look, MAEPEOR Matte Liquid Eyeshadow 8 Colors Neutral Naked Smooth Creamy Eyeshadow is a great choice. It’s a lightweight and creamy liquid texture that allows you to create a smooth, natural matte eye makeup in the blink of an eye.
Pros
- The matte creamy texture goes on smoothly like silk without clumping, skipping or smudging.
- The smudge-proof, quick-drying formula means you don’t have to worry about shedding eye makeup after sweating.
- This liquid eyeshadow is not only waterproof and sweatproof but also maintains high-pigmentation eye makeup all day, regardless of humidity and hot weather.
Cons
- The colors are not as intense for one coat as the advertisement may imply.
- The colors do not blend well and can rub off instead of blend.
- The box may arrive opened or damaged.
This liquid eye shadow can be applied smoothly, even beginners can enjoy the easy application and glamorous effect in seconds. It’s easy to remove without worrying about pigmentation. With an unique package, it’s an ideal gift for girls or ladies on Birthday Party, Cosmetic Show, Live Show, Prom Night, Dance Party, Wedding Makeup. (Cruelty-free. No tested on animals.)
Overall, MAEPEOR Matte Liquid Eyeshadow 8 Colors Neutral Naked Smooth Creamy Eyeshadow is a great choice for those looking for a natural and neutral look that lasts all day.
LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Blend Away Rosy & Rustic 8 Multi-Finish Eyeshadows 12 Blend Away Rosy & Rustic 8 Multi-Finish Eyeshadows
We highly recommend the LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Blend Away Rosy & Rustic 8 Multi-Finish Eyeshadows. The eyeshadow palette includes 8 pressed shades in beautiful rosy tones, both in a range of shimmer and matte eyeshadow finishes. The mix of berry and floral-inspired tones let you create nude eyeshadow looks and rosy pink eyeshadow looks alike.
Pros
- The eyeshadows blend beautifully on your lids with rich color payoff.
- The palette includes both matte and shimmer eyeshadows for creating any beautiful combination you can dream of.
- Perfect for travel and on the go.
Cons
- The palette is somewhat expensive.
- One of the shadows came crushed for some customers.
- The eyeshadow isn’t as pigmented as other brands.
The LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Blend Away Rosy & Rustic 8 Multi-Finish Eyeshadows palette is perfect for creating a variety of looks, whether you prefer a natural, nude look or a more dramatic, rosy look. The velvety smooth eyeshadows blend beautifully on your lids with rich color payoff. The palette includes both matte and shimmer eyeshadows for creating any beautiful combination you can dream of. It is also perfect for travel and on the go.
The only downside is that the palette is somewhat expensive and one of the shadows came crushed for some customers. Additionally, the eyeshadow isn’t as pigmented as other brands. However, if you’re looking for a versatile eyeshadow palette with beautiful rosy tones, the LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Blend Away Rosy & Rustic 8 Multi-Finish Eyeshadows is definitely worth considering.
Kaely 8Pcs Cream Eyeshadow Stick Set for Eyes
If you’re looking for a versatile eyeshadow set that’s easy to use and perfect for everyday wear, the Kaely 8Pcs Cream Eyeshadow Stick Set for Eyes might be just what you need.
Pros
- Achieve flawless eye makeup in seconds with this shimmering eyeshadow stick set.
- Goes on smoothly like silk without clumping, skipping or smudging.
- Powder waterproof and long-lasting, stay on up to 10-12 hours wear!
Cons
- The colors may not be as pigmented as expected.
- Some users may find the eyeshadow to be too shimmery.
- The product may not work well for people with oily eyelids.
We were impressed with how easy it was to apply the eyeshadow sticks, and how quickly we were able to achieve a polished look. The sticks are silky and go on smoothly, without clumping or smudging. We also appreciated the waterproof and long-lasting formula, which helped keep our makeup looking fresh throughout the day.
While the colors in the set are versatile and can be used to create a range of looks, some users may find that the pigmentation is not as strong as they would like. Additionally, the shimmer in the eyeshadow may not be to everyone’s taste, and some people with oily eyelids may find that the product doesn’t work well for them.
Overall, we would recommend the Kaely 8Pcs Cream Eyeshadow Stick Set for Eyes to anyone looking for an easy-to-use, versatile set of eyeshadows. The waterproof and long-lasting formula makes it perfect for everyday wear, and the range of colors means you’ll have plenty of options for creating different looks.
HOOMUSS Black Smoky Eye Shadow Palette 8Color, Dark Grey Smokey Eyeshadow for Goth Makeup, Black Silver White Gray Shade for Halloween, Pigmented & Long Lasting (Black)
If you’re looking for a dark, smoky eyeshadow palette, the HOOMUSS Black Smoky Eye Shadow Palette is an excellent choice. With eight pressed powder shades in black, silver, white, and gray, this palette is perfect for creating a variety of smokey eye looks.
Pros
- The rich color payoff and long-lasting formula ensures that your smokey eye look will last all day and night.
- The matte and shimmer finishes allow you to create a range of different looks, from soft and romantic to bold and goth.
- The palette is super creamy, velvety soft, and easy to blend, making it perfect for all skin types and skin tones.
Cons
- Some customers have reported that the eyeshadow is a little dry and hard to apply.
- The palette is quite small, so it may not be the best choice if you’re looking for a lot of product.
- The packaging is not the most durable, so you may need to be careful when traveling with it.
Overall, we highly recommend the HOOMUSS Black Smoky Eye Shadow Palette for anyone looking for a high-quality, versatile eyeshadow palette. Whether you’re going for a soft, romantic look or a bold, gothic vibe, this palette has everything you need to create the perfect smokey eye.
SUMEITANG 8 Colors Matte Liquid Eyeshadow Set
If you’re looking for a quick and easy way to create a stunning eye makeup look, the SUMEITANG 8 Colors Matte Liquid Eyeshadow Set is a great option.
Pros
- The highly pigmented, easy-to-apply formula makes it perfect for both beginners and experienced makeup artists.
- The quick-drying, waterproof and long-lasting formula ensures that your eye makeup stays in place all day, even in humid and hot weather.
- The set comes with 8 neutral naked shades that are perfect for all skin tones and eye shapes.
Cons
- The applicator might be too small for some users.
- The eyeshadow dries quickly, so it might be difficult to spread out.
- The eyeshadow might be hard to remove, so make sure to use a good makeup remover.
The silky smooth eyeshadow is made with high-quality ingredients and has a lightweight, liquid texture that allows you to create a smooth, natural matte advanced hazy feeling eye makeup in the blink of an eye. You can use the eyeshadow color alone for a natural neutral nude shade or mix it with other shimmery eyeshadows for a gorgeous eye look!
The set comes in a unique and sophisticated packaging, making it a perfect gift for good friends and family. It’s suitable for many occasions, such as birthday party, wedding, cosmetic show, live show, prom night and dance party.
Overall, if you’re looking for a high-quality, easy-to-use eyeshadow set that will give you stunning eye makeup looks, the SUMEITANG 8 Colors Matte Liquid Eyeshadow Set is definitely worth considering.
L.A. COLORS 16 Color Eyeshadow Palette
We highly recommend the L.A. COLORS 16 Color Eyeshadow Palette for anyone looking for a versatile and affordable eyeshadow set.
Pros
- The vibrant colors are perfect for creating a wide range of looks.
- The palette includes both matte and shimmer finishes for added versatility.
- The dual ended applicator is convenient for on-the-go touch-ups.
Cons
- The eyeshadows can be a bit powdery, resulting in fallout during application.
- Some users have reported that the pigmentation could be stronger.
- The packaging is not the most durable and may break over time.
If you’re looking for a budget-friendly eyeshadow palette that still delivers great results, the L.A. COLORS 16 Color Eyeshadow Palette is definitely worth considering. The palette includes a mix of matte and shimmer shades in a range of vibrant colors, making it easy to create any look you desire. Plus, the dual ended applicator is perfect for touch-ups on the go.
The only downsides to this palette are that the eyeshadows can be a bit powdery and may result in fallout during application. Additionally, some users have reported that the pigmentation could be stronger. However, for the price point, these cons are relatively minor.
Overall, we think the L.A. COLORS 16 Color Eyeshadow Palette is a great choice for anyone looking to experiment with different eyeshadow looks without breaking the bank.
Buying Guide
When it comes to choosing the best eyeshadow, there are a few key features to consider. We’ve compiled a list of factors to keep in mind to help you make an informed decision.
Color Selection
The first thing to consider when choosing an eyeshadow is the color selection. Look for a palette that offers a range of shades that complement your skin tone and eye color. Neutral tones like beige, brown, and taupe are versatile and work well for everyday wear, while bold colors like blue, green, and purple can add a pop of color to your look.
Texture
The texture of the eyeshadow is another important factor to consider. Matte eyeshadows are great for creating a natural, subtle look, while shimmer and metallic shades can add dimension and sparkle. Cream eyeshadows are easy to apply and blend, while powder eyeshadows offer more control and precision.
Longevity
Nobody wants their eyeshadow to smudge or fade halfway through the day. Look for a long-lasting formula that will stay put for hours without creasing or flaking. Waterproof and smudge-proof formulas are also great for ensuring your eyeshadow stays in place.
Application
The ease of application is another important factor to consider. Look for an eyeshadow that comes with an applicator or brush for easy and precise application. Some palettes also come with a mirror, which is great for on-the-go touch-ups.
Price
Eyeshadows come in a range of prices, from drugstore to high-end. Consider your budget and how often you’ll be using the product when making your decision. Keep in mind that higher-priced products may offer better quality and longevity, but that doesn’t mean you can’t find a great product at a lower price point.
By considering these factors, you’ll be able to choose the best eyeshadow for your needs and preferences.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top-rated eyeshadow brands for vibrant pigmentation?
When it comes to vibrant pigmentation, some of the top-rated eyeshadow brands are Anastasia Beverly Hills, Huda Beauty, and Pat McGrath Labs. These brands have a wide range of shades that are highly pigmented and long-lasting.
Which eyeshadow palettes are recommended for makeup beginners?
For makeup beginners, we recommend starting with a neutral eyeshadow palette that has a mix of matte and shimmer shades. Some good options include the Tartelette In Bloom Clay Eyeshadow Palette, the Urban Decay Naked Basics Eyeshadow Palette, and the Too Faced Natural Matte Eyeshadow Palette.
How do I choose the best eyeshadow palette for my eye color?
When choosing an eyeshadow palette for your eye color, it’s important to consider complementary shades. For blue eyes, warm browns, oranges, and golds can make your eyes pop. For green eyes, purples, pinks, and browns can bring out the green tones. For brown eyes, blues, greens, and purples can create a striking contrast.
